My stepmother handed me a hideous forty-year-old dress for prom and told my father she’d spent hours choosing it.
At nine o’clock the gym ran its thirty-year slideshow, and a photograph from 1998 came up on a nine-foot screen — my mother, at seventeen, in the exact dress I was standing in.
Chapter 1: Mustard-Gold
My mom d*ed three years before prom.
My name is Cressida, and for a while it was just me and my dad.
Then he met Alexis.
Within months she and her daughter Brianna moved into our house. Brianna was my age, went to my school, and from the very beginning neither of them liked me.
I want to be fair about the beginning, because it is the part people skip.
Alexis was good to my father.
He had been eleven months a widower and he had stopped eating properly, and she made him laugh in a kitchen in April and I was genuinely glad. I told my aunt so. I have the text.
It changed in the second year and it changed in small ways.
Alexis adored her daughter. Everything Brianna did was amazing. Everything I did was somehow wrong — the tone I used, the way I loaded a dishwasher, the fact that I kept a photograph of my mother on the hall table where guests could see it.
That last one came up four times.
Then prom season arrived.
Dad gave Alexis money to buy dresses for both of us, which he announced at dinner like a man solving something, and for a moment I thought maybe she was finally trying.
I should have known better.
Brianna got a gorgeous ice-blue designer ball gown. Fitted bodice, tulle skirt, the whole thing.
Mine looked like a thrift store find.
The color was awful — dull mustard-gold, high collar, long sleeves, forty years out of date, the fabric slightly stiff at the seams the way old fabric goes.
Even Brianna laughed when she saw it.
But Alexis acted offended. “I spent hours looking for that dress.”
Dad told me I should appreciate the effort.
That is the sentence I have had the hardest time with, and I will come back to it, because my father is not a stupid man and he had that dress in his own house for three weeks.
I knew arguing wouldn’t change anything. Besides, after graduation I was leaving for college, four states away, and I had been counting weeks since January.
So on prom night I put it on.
When we walked into the gym every head turned to Brianna. She looked stunning; I want that on the record too, because it is true and because it is not the point.
Then she pointed at me and laughed.
“Oh my God. Did someone lose a bet?”
Several people laughed. Then more joined in.
Soon they whispered every time I walked past. A few asked if it came from a costume shop. One boy asked, not unkindly, whether it was a bit — whether I was making a statement.
I said no.
Brianna loved every second.
And every time I looked across the gym I could see Alexis among the parent chaperones, smiling.
I stood by the drinks table for about forty minutes wishing the floor would swallow me whole.
There was one person in that gym who did not laugh.
A girl named Wilhelmina Aubry, who I had spoken to perhaps four times in three years, who was on the yearbook committee and who spent most of that evening behind a camera.
She came and stood next to me at the drinks table at about twenty to nine.
She did not say anything kind. She did not say ignore them. She said: “Do you want me to take a proper one?”
“Of what?”
“Of the dress,” said Wilhelmina. “Not a candid. A proper one. Because it’s handmade and nobody in this room can tell, and in eleven years you’re going to want a photograph where you don’t look like you’re being laughed at.”
Because it’s handmade and nobody in this room can tell.
She was seventeen and she had spent two hours looking through a viewfinder at a garment and had worked out, entirely on her own, the single fact that reorganized that entire night — and she worked it out twenty minutes before the slideshow did it for everybody else.
She took four photographs by the trophy case.
I have them. One is framed.
In it I am standing straight, in my mother’s dress, in the gym my mother stood in, at twenty to nine in the evening, twenty minutes before I knew anything — and I am not smiling, and I do not look hum*liated either.
I look like somebody who has just been asked a question about fabric.
At nine o’clock the music stopped for the slideshow.
Our school has done it for thirty years — every prom photographed, every year on a reel, and the seniors watch four decades of their own parents go by while everybody shrieks at the hair.
1998 came up.
And the gym went completely silent.
Because there, on a nine-foot screen, in the center of a photograph taken in that exact gym, was a seventeen-year-old girl with my face.
My mother. Sable.
In a dull mustard-gold dress with a high collar and long sleeves.
The same dress. The one I was standing in.
Somebody screamed. Somebody else started clapping without knowing why.
And across that gym I watched my stepmother’s face come apart in real time — because Alexis had not bought that dress at a thrift store.
She had taken it out of the boxes in our garage.
The ones with my mother’s name on them in my father’s handwriting. The ones he has never let anybody open.
And my father was due at nine-fifteen to chaperone the second half.
She came across that gym floor so fast she lost a shoe.
“Take it off.” Her hands were shaking. “Cressida. Please. Take it off right now.”
Chapter 2: Nine-Fourteen
I did not take it off.
I want to be honest that this was not defiance. I could not have taken it off; there were four hundred people in that room and I was wearing my mother.
What I actually did was stand there.
“Cressida.” Alexis had her hand on my arm. “Go and wait in the car. I’ll tell him you felt sick.”
“You went in the boxes.”
“Listen to me—”
“He doesn’t let anybody in those boxes.”
And Alexis Trembley, forty-four years old, in front of about eleven teenagers who had stopped pretending not to listen, said the sentence that told me exactly how long she had been planning it.
“It was in the third one. Under the coats.”
The third one.
She had opened at least three.
Somewhere in my father’s garage, on some afternoon when nobody was home, my stepmother had gone through my mother’s boxes one at a time until she found something ugly enough.
And she had found something that was not ugly at all.
It was homemade.
That is what nobody in that gym understood yet, and what I did not understand for another nine minutes: the stiffness at the seams, the high collar, the sleeves — my mother made that dress in 1998 on her own mother’s machine, because there was no money for a prom dress that year, and she wore it to that gym and she was photographed in it.
To Alexis it looked like a thrift shop reject.
She was not wrong about that, exactly. It looks like what it is: a seventeen-year-old’s homemade dress.
That’s why she picked it.
At nine-fourteen the gym doors opened and my father walked in with two other parents, holding a tray of cups from the concession table, because he had offered to help, because he is that man.
He got four steps in.
The slideshow had moved on to 2003 by then. The gym was loud again. Nobody was looking at the doors.
And my father stopped in the middle of that floor and looked at me across four hundred people and dropped the tray.
Chapter 3: The Third Box
He did not shout.
I have been asked about that a lot, and people are always disappointed. There was no scene. My father crossed that gym, and the plastic cups were rolling everywhere, and he stopped about four feet away from me and did not touch me.
There is one detail from those four steps that I did not understand for months.
He was not looking at my face.
Four hundred people in that gym, his daughter in the middle of it, and my father’s eyes went straight to the collar — and I have since worked out why, and it is the worst small fact in this whole account.
He had looked for that dress in March.
Not consciously. He had gone into the garage for something else, some ordinary Saturday errand, and had noticed that one box was taped differently, and had stood there for a while and then decided he was being morbid and gone back inside.
He told me that in the car, eleven months later, in the flat voice he uses for things he has decided to stop protecting me from.
“I saw the tape, Cress. In March. I stood in front of it and told myself I was grieving wrong.”
That is what she was actually counting on.
Not that nobody would notice. That a man three years into it would decide his noticing was the problem.
He said: “Turn around.”
So I turned around.
He was looking at the back of the collar, where my grandmother’s machine had gone wrong in 1998 and my mother had unpicked it and done it again by hand, and there are two rows of stitching there instead of one.
He knew about the two rows.
“Cress,” he said. Then nothing for about eleven seconds. “Who gave you this dress?”
I did not answer.
That is the one thing I did that night that I am still proud of, and it was not loyalty: I knew that if I said it, it would be a girl accusing her stepmother at a school dance, and half that room would decide I was dramatic.
So I said nothing, and my father turned around.
And Alexis was standing eleven feet away with one shoe on.
That was all it took.
Alexis tried once more before they left.
She got between my father and the doors, and she said — quietly, quickly, in the voice of somebody with about four seconds to work with — “She’s had a hard night, she’s confusing things, she’s been going through her mother’s boxes for weeks.”
That was the last thing my stepmother ever said in front of me.
She tried to put it on me.
See more on the next page
