The Apple Tree
A Story About Neighbors, Children, and the Quiet Ways You Teach Someone What Kind of Person They Are
There are people who will tell you that you should never let things with neighbors go unaddressed.
There are other people who will tell you that neighbor conflicts are the ones most worth avoiding, because you cannot choose your neighbors the way you choose your friends, and you have to see them every day, and the cost of a bad relationship with the person next door is paid in small, daily increments for as long as you both live there.
Both of these pieces of advice are correct.
This story is about what happens when you hold both of them at the same time and find the narrow path between them — the one that requires you to be smarter than you want to be when someone has hurt your children and your instinct is to stand on your deck and say every true thing you know about them at full volume.
It is also, at its heart, a story about an apple tree.
And what it means to know the difference between what is technically yours and what is actually right.
Dale Mercer moved in next door eleven years ago.
I know this because we moved in twelve years ago, which means I was still in the honeymoon phase of the house — the phase where everything about the neighborhood feels like possibility, where you learn which neighbors wave back and which ones don’t, where you figure out the unspoken rules of how your particular street works.
Dale was already there when we arrived. He had been there for years, apparently. He knew the drainage pattern of the block and where the property lines technically fell and which utility company owned which pole. He was the kind of neighbor who possessed a great deal of technical information about shared spaces and was not shy about deploying it.
He was not warm.
He wasn’t cruel, exactly, not at first — just closed in the way that some people are closed, armored with the specific self-sufficiency of someone who has decided that other people are primarily a source of problems. He maintained his property carefully. He kept to himself. He nodded when you passed him on the street and did not initiate conversation.
We coexisted.
For the first few years, coexistence was enough.
The apple tree predated all of us.
It was an old tree, the kind that had been growing long enough to have real presence — gnarled, substantial, its canopy spread wide in the way of trees that have been allowed to develop without interference. It sat near the property line, but not on it. It was Dale’s tree, unambiguously, by deed and by common sense. No one had ever disputed this.
What the tree did not respect was the property line.
A full third of its canopy extended over our yard. This is not unusual with old trees — they grow toward light, they spread indifferently, they do not consult property surveys before putting out new branches. What this meant, practically, was that every August, a significant portion of Dale’s apple harvest landed in our grass.
Not a few apples.
Buckets of apples.
I don’t know what variety the tree was. Tart, small, the kind that make excellent sauce if you’re in the mood to make apple sauce, which I learned in the second year when I had so many that I had to do something. They came down in waves — first the early windfalls, the ones that gave up before they were ready, and then the main drop in late August, when the grass under our swing set and through our flower bed and across half the back lawn was carpeted in them.
I had raked apples for nine years.
Rob had raked apples for nine years.
The apple that rotted into the paint on our shed was not an anomaly — it was the logical consequence of a hundred apples coming down faster than we could clear them, one of them landing at the base of the wall and staying there through rain and heat until it became part of the surface it had rested against.
The mark was still there.
Dale had never helped with any of this. Not a word of acknowledgment that his tree was creating labor on our side of the fence. Not an offer to split the fruit, or to send his grandson over to help with the clearing, or even a thank-you for the years of maintenance we had absorbed without complaint.
This was the context.
Nine years of context, stacked up like apples in a bucket, waiting.
My daughter Maya turned six in April.
She has Rob’s patience and my grandmother’s red hair and a way of approaching the physical world with her whole body that is exhausting to watch and magnificent at the same time. She does not do things halfway. When she was learning to ride her bike, she practiced until she either had it or fell off, no middle ground, no cautious halfway measures. When she decided she wanted to plant a garden last spring, she planted it with the conviction of someone who has studied the project and committed to the result.
She is, in other words, a person who sees something that needs doing and does it.
Leo is nine, and he is the more analytical of the two — the one who needs to understand why before he will commit to the how. He asks questions before he acts, which has saved him from several of Maya’s more ambitious schemes over the years. He has a quality of stillness that Maya does not, the ability to watch a situation before deciding what it means.
On Sunday afternoon, after lunch, they went into the backyard.
I was on the deck with my coffee, not paying close attention, doing the particular Sunday unfocusing that the afternoon allows. I watched them peripherally. Maya was carrying something. Then she was carrying something again. It took me three or four of these trips before I understood what I was watching.
She had found the old bucket in the garage — the big blue one we used for gardening — and she and Leo were picking up apples.
Not to bring inside. To bring to the fence.
They were clearing the yard without being asked, which was already remarkable, and they were taking the apples to the property line, which in their minds was obviously the right destination. The tree belonged to Dale. The apples came from the tree. Where else would you take them?
Children’s logic.
Pure, simple, correct.
I was watching this with the warmth of a mother who has just seen her children do something generous and unprompted when Dale came out.
He was at the fence before they reached it with the first load.
“Those are mine,” he said.
Leo stopped. “What?”
“All of them. Every one that came off my tree. Bring them to the fence.”
“They fell on our side.”
“Doesn’t matter where they land. It’s my tree.”
I stood up from my chair.
Leo and Maya looked at each other.
And then they did it.
Because they were children who had been raised to respect adults, even adults who were not being respectful back, they began picking up the apples. Not just the ones they had already gathered. The ones in the flower bed. The ones under the swing set. The ones in the far corner of the yard that had bounced and rolled into the shadow of the fence.
Maya couldn’t hold more than three at a time.
She was six. She had small arms and the apples were uneven and awkward.
Four trips. She made four trips.
She kept looking up at the deck.
I said his name. Once. Dale.
He didn’t turn his head.
He stood at the fence and took the apples one load at a time, dropping them into a bag, and he did not look at the children or at me, and when the last apple had been delivered and the bag was closed, he looked up and he saw me.
“Nice,” he said. “Raising thieves young, are we?”
Maya started crying.
Leo didn’t.
Leo stood in the middle of the yard with his hands dirty and his ears red, looking at the ground, and I have thought about that image many times since because the thing about a child who doesn’t cry when they have been hurt is that the not-crying is often more heartbreaking than the crying. It means they have swallowed it. It means they have already begun the process of deciding what kind of person they are going to be in response to the kind of person they have encountered.
I wanted to decide that for him.
I wanted to march to that fence and teach him a different lesson.
I photographed it instead.
Not dramatically. I took two photographs through the deck railing — Maya wiping her face, Leo in the yard with his hands at his sides — and I sent them to Rob with one line: He stood at the fence and made them hand over every apple in our yard.
See more on the next page
