Skip to content

My Brother Chose the Cheapest Cremation Box for Dad Then Mom Went to the Barn and Pulled a Tarp Off Something He Built in 1988

  • by

JULIE HELPED. 1988.

I didn’t remember either.

Gary Nygaard came at three o’clock with the hearse and four men.

He stood in the barn door and looked at the casket for a long time without saying anything. He’s been a funeral director for forty-one years. He has seen every kind of casket there is.

He walked over slowly. He ran his hand along the side. He bent down and looked at the dovetails. He opened the lid and looked inside.

The inside was lined with white cotton. Quilted. Hand-stitched.

“Marlys,” he said. “Who did the lining?”

“I did,” Mom said. “That same winter. On my mother’s treadle machine. I used the cotton from my wedding dress. It was all we had that was nice enough.”

Gary closed the lid. He stood there with his hand on it.

“In forty-one years,” he said, “I’ve never seen anything like this.”

“Hank would have said it’s just a box.”

“Hank would have been wrong.” Gary looked at her. “And he’d have known it.”

Then he did something I didn’t expect. He took off his hat.

The other four men took off their hats too.

They lifted it. It took all five of them, plus Kevin. Dad had built it out of inch-and-a-quarter pine, heavy on purpose. They carried it out of the barn and across the yard through the snow, slowly, while Mom and I walked behind.

When they slid it into the back of the hearse, Gary turned around.

“Marlys, I’m going to take care of him myself. I’ll call you tonight about the service.”

“Thank you, Gary.”

“And Marlys? There’s no charge for anything. Not the preparation. Not the service. Not the hearse.”

“Gary, no.”

“Hank built my porch,” Gary said. “In 1983. When my wife was pregnant with our first and I couldn’t afford to pay him till spring. He said, pay me when you can. I paid him in April. He tore up the bill and said the porch was a baby present.”

He put his hat back on.

“There’s no charge,” he said. “That’s the end of the discussion.”

He drove away.

We stood in the driveway in the snow, the three of us. Watching the hearse go down Third Street.

“How many porches did he build?” Kevin said quietly.

“Three hundred and twelve,” Mom said. “He kept a list.”

“Where’s the list?”

“In the glove box of his truck.”

Kevin walked over to Dad’s truck. It was still parked by the barn where he’d left it Wednesday night. He opened the passenger door. He opened the glove box.

There was the spiral notebook. Green cover. Soft from being handled for thirty years.

He brought it inside and sat at the kitchen table and read it. Every page. Every name.

It took him two hours. Mom and I didn’t interrupt him.

When he was done, he looked up.

“Mom. Can I make some phone calls?”

The funeral was Wednesday at Our Savior’s Lutheran.

Under the bell tower Dad built in 1979.

Kevin had made phone calls for three days. He’d gone through the whole notebook. Every name. Most of the people were still alive. Some of the houses had changed hands. When they had, Kevin called the new owners and told them who’d built their porch.

He didn’t ask anybody to come. He just told them.

I don’t know how many calls he made. I know he didn’t sleep much. I know that on Monday night I found him sitting at the kitchen table at one in the morning with the notebook open and the phone in his hand and tears running down his face, and when I asked him if he was okay, he said, “Julie, I just talked to a woman whose husband proposed to her on a porch Dad built. In 1977. She said they sat on it every night for forty-four years until he died.”

The church holds about three hundred people.

By the time the service started, there were over five hundred. They stood in the aisles. They stood along the walls. They stood in the narthex and on the front steps and out on the sidewalk in the cold.

Gary Nygaard set up speakers outside so the people on the sidewalk could hear.

The casket sat at the front of the church on a plain wooden stand. Gary had polished it with linseed oil. It glowed under the lights like honey. The rope handles were still there. The little carved hands at either end of the lid were facing up, where everybody could see them.

Kevin had asked Gary to make sure of that.

Pastor Lindgren did the service. He talked about Dad and the bell tower. He talked about Jesus being a carpenter, which every pastor says at every carpenter’s funeral, and Dad would have rolled his eyes at it. Then he did something unusual.

He asked if anybody in the church was sitting on a porch my father built.

Not literally. But he asked them to stand up. If Hank Sorensen had ever built a porch for them, or for their parents, or for the house they lived in now.

I turned around in the front pew.

They stood up.

All over the church. In every pew. Along the walls. In the narthex. You could hear the people out on the sidewalk shuffling and murmuring through the open doors.

More than half the church was standing.

Old men in seed caps. Young families with babies. A woman in her nineties who had to be lifted up by her grandsons. The Christiansons, whose porch had made him miss Kevin’s graduation party in 2000. Their baby was a grown man now. He stood next to his mother with his own baby on his hip.

Kevin was sitting next to me.

He looked at all of them.

Then he stood up too.

He didn’t have a porch. He lived in an apartment in Alexandria since the divorce.

But he stood up anyway. And he put his hand on the end of the casket, right over the little carved hand.

And he kept it there.The pallbearers were the six oldest men on Dad’s list.

Kevin had called them himself. Every one of them had a porch my father built before 1975. Every one of them said yes before he finished asking.

The youngest was seventy-eight. The oldest was ninety-three. That was Olaf Brandvold, Dad’s old teacher. He’d said he could still carry his end. Gary Nygaard quietly put two of his own men on either side of the old ones, just in case. But the six old men did the carrying.

When they lifted that casket off the stand at the end of the service, I held my breath.

Six old men. Inch-and-a-quarter pine. Rope handles.

Not one of the handles moved. Not even a little.

They carried him down the center aisle under the bell tower he built, and out the front doors, and down the church steps.

And on the steps, Olaf stopped.

Everybody stopped behind him. The whole church. Five hundred people.

Olaf was holding the front left handle. He looked down at the steps.

“This is where Arne’s handle came off,” he said. Loud enough for everybody near the front to hear. “In 1987. Right here on this step. I was carrying that one too.”

He looked back at the casket.

“Hank swore it wouldn’t happen to him.”

He gripped the rope tighter.

“It’s not going to.”

They carried him down the steps.

The handles held.

I heard Kevin, behind me, let out a breath he must have been holding since the barn.

At the cemetery, Mom stood at the graveside in the snow. She didn’t cry during the committal. She stood very straight in her church coat with her hands folded.

When Pastor Lindgren finished, Mom stepped forward. She took off her glove. She put her bare hand on the lid of the casket, right in the middle, between the two little carved hands.

She held it there for a long time.

Then she said something. Very quietly. I was right beside her and I almost didn’t hear it.

“You were right, Hank. Nobody carried you out in cardboard.”

She put her glove back on.

Then she turned to Kevin.

“Help me back to the car, honey.”

He took her arm.

That night, everybody came back to the house. The church ladies had brought ham and scalloped potatoes and bars and three different Jell-O salads. The house was full. People sat on every chair and on the stairs and out on the porch in their coats, in the cold, because there wasn’t room inside.

They sat on Dad’s porch. The wraparound one with the turned spindles and the swing.

I went out to bring them coffee. Kevin was out there. He was sitting on the porch swing with the green notebook in his lap.

An old man was sitting next to him. I didn’t know him.

“That’s the Dahl place,” the old man was saying. He was pointing to a page in the notebook. “On Fourth. Nineteen seventy-one. Your dad built that porch with my brother. My brother died in Vietnam that spring. Hank finished it alone. Wouldn’t take any money from my mother.”

Kevin was writing something in the margin. Next to the name.

“What are you doing?” I asked him later, when the man had gone inside.

“Writing down the stories,” Kevin said. “Dad only wrote the names. Somebody should write down what happened.”

He’d been doing it all night. Every person who came out on the porch, he asked them. Which porch. What happened. He wrote it in the margins in his small, cramped handwriting.

“Kev,” I said. “You don’t have to do all of them tonight.”

“I know.” He kept writing. “I’m going to do all of them, though. All three hundred and twelve. I’m going to drive around and knock on every door.”

“That’ll take a year.”

“Good,” Kevin said. “I’ve got a year.”

He closed the notebook.

He was quiet for a while. Then he said, “Julie. I was going to put him in a cardboard box.”

“I know.”

“I said he wouldn’t know the difference.”

“I know, Kev.”

“I hated him. For a long time. I really did. For missing everything. I thought he didn’t care.” He looked at his hands. “And the whole time, there was a box in the barn with my handprint on it.”

“You didn’t know.”

“I didn’t ask.” He shook his head. “That’s worse. I never once went out to the barn and asked what he was doing. Not after I was ten. I just decided I knew.”

He was quiet a long time.

“He would’ve told me,” Kevin said. “If I’d asked. He would’ve shown me. I bet he waited for me to come out there for thirty years.”

I didn’t say anything. There wasn’t anything to say.

I sat down on the swing next to him. We swung a little. The chains creaked, the way they’ve creaked my whole life.

“Do you think he forgave me?” Kevin said.

I looked at him.

“Kevin. He carved your name on his casket.”

It’s been a year now.

Kevin did it. He knocked on every door. All three hundred and twelve. He did it on Saturdays and Sundays and some weeknights after work. Some of the houses had been torn down. Some of the porches had been replaced. But most were still there. Most of the people let him in.

He wrote down every story. He filled up the margins of the green notebook, and then three more notebooks after that.

In the spring, he quit the car lot.

He went to work for a carpenter in Glenwood named Pete Sundberg. Pete is fifty-eight. He’d worked with Dad in the nineties. Pete is teaching Kevin framing. Finish work. Stairs.

And porches.

Kevin built his first one in September. For an old woman in Starbuck whose porch, built by my father in 1981, had finally rotted through.

He built it exactly the way Dad would have. Turned spindles. A swing at the end. He sent me a picture.

At the bottom of the top step, where nobody would see it unless they were looking, he’d carved two small things into the wood.

A hand. A man’s hand. Traced and carved.

And three words.

HANK HELPED. 2026.

Mom still lives in the house on Third Street. She sits on the porch every evening when the weather’s warm enough. Sometimes Kevin comes over and sits with her.

She gave Kevin the barn. All of Dad’s tools. The table saw. The planer. The lathe. The percolator on the workbench.

Last month, Kevin called me.

“Julie. I need you to come out to the barn this weekend.”

“Why?”

“Just come. Bring the kids.”

I drove out Saturday with my two. They’re twelve and nine.

Kevin had a stack of white pine on the sawhorses. Clear, straight boards. Inch-and-a-quarter thick.

“What’s this for?” I asked.

“Mom,” Kevin said.

I stared at him.

“She’s not sick, Julie. Relax. She’s fine.” He picked up a board and sighted down the edge. “But she’s eighty. And Dad built his in 1988. He said a person ought to have it ready. So nobody’s scrambling. So nobody’s sitting in Gary’s office signing a paper for ninety-five dollars.”

He set the board down.

“I asked her. She cried. Then she said yes. Then she said it better be as good as his.”

“Is it going to be?”

“No,” Kevin said. “But it’s going to be close.”

He handed my twelve-year-old a small block of wood with sandpaper wrapped around it.

“You get the inside of the boards,” he said. “Where nobody’s ever going to see. That’s the most important part.”

My son looked at him. “Why’s it the most important part if nobody sees it?”

Kevin looked down at the casket in the corner of the barn where Dad’s had sat for thirty-seven years. The spot was empty now, except for the outline of clean floor where the dust had never settled.

“Because somebody always finds out eventually,” he said. “And when they do, you want them to know you did it right.”

My son started sanding.

Kevin picked up his carpenter’s pencil. The one Dad always kept behind the vise handle. He held it out to my nine-year-old daughter.

“Come here, sweetheart,” he said. “Put your hand down flat on this board. Spread your fingers wide.”

She did.

And my brother traced around it.

See more on the next page

2 of 3

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *