Based on the visible marbling alone, I would lean toward Number 3, provided it is similar in thickness to the other steaks.
Its central muscle appears well developed, and the fine white streaks of fat are distributed across a broad area of the meat. Those are attractive characteristics for a ribeye intended for high-heat grilling.
However, this is a visual preference, not a definitive ranking of quality. Number 1, Number 2, Number 6, or another steak could be just as good—or better—depending on thickness, tenderness, beef grade, aging, and the distribution of the ribeye cap.
If I were selecting a steak in person, I would prioritize these features:
- Fine, well-distributed intramuscular marbling.
- A thickness of approximately 1¼–1½ inches.
- A well-developed central muscle.
- A reasonable balance of meat and fat.
- Freshness and a reliable source.
Ultimately, the best ribeye is the one that matches your preferences for richness, texture, and portion size.
How to Grill the Perfect Ribeye Steak: Step by Step
Once you’ve selected your steak, the cooking technique is just as important as the cut itself.
Ingredients
- 1 ribeye steak, approximately 1¼–1½ inches thick
- 1 teaspoon kosher salt, or to taste
- ½ teaspoon freshly ground black pepper
- 1 teaspoon neutral, high-heat cooking oil, if needed
- 1 tablespoon unsalted butter, optional
- 1–2 garlic cloves, optional
- 1 sprig fresh rosemary or thyme, optional
Step 1: Prepare the Steak
Remove the steak from its packaging and pat it thoroughly dry with paper towels.
A dry surface helps the meat develop a deep brown crust when it touches the hot grill.
Season both sides with salt and freshly ground black pepper.
For the best flavor, salt the steak in advance and refrigerate it uncovered on a rack for several hours or overnight. If you do not have time, seasoning immediately before grilling also works well.
Step 2: Preheat the Grill
Preheat your grill thoroughly to high heat.
If possible, establish two cooking zones: one for direct, high-heat searing and another for lower-heat cooking.
Clean the grill grates and lightly oil them if necessary, using an appropriate method that avoids dripping oil into the flames.
A properly heated grill helps develop the flavorful crust that makes a great ribeye so appealing.
Step 3: Sear the First Side
Place the steak over direct heat.
For a steak around 1¼–1½ inches thick, begin by searing for approximately 2–3 minutes, depending on the grill’s temperature.
Avoid moving the steak constantly. Allow the surface to brown before turning it.
The goal is a deeply browned crust rather than simply dark grill marks.
Step 4: Turn and Sear the Other Side
Flip the steak and sear the second side for another 2–3 minutes.
If the fat cap is thick, you can briefly hold the steak with tongs to render some of that exterior fat.
Watch for flare-ups, especially with heavily marbled steaks. Move the steak to the cooler zone if flames become excessive.
Step 5: Finish Cooking to Your Preferred Doneness
After searing both sides, move the steak to the cooler side of the grill if the center needs more time.
Continue cooking, turning occasionally, until the steak reaches your preferred internal temperature.
Use an instant-read thermometer inserted into the thickest part of the meat, avoiding large pockets of fat.
For whole beef steaks, the USDA recommends a minimum internal temperature of 145°F (63°C), followed by a three-minute rest, for food safety.
For people who prefer less-cooked steak, cooking temperatures are often described as follows:
- Rare: approximately 120–125°F (49–52°C).
- Medium-rare: approximately 130–135°F (54–57°C).
- Medium: approximately 140–145°F (60–63°C).
- Medium-well: approximately 150–155°F (66–68°C).
- Well-done: approximately 160°F (71°C) or higher.
These are common culinary doneness ranges, not all food-safety recommendations. The USDA’s recommended minimum remains 145°F with a three-minute rest.
Remember that the temperature may rise slightly after the steak leaves the grill, so account for carryover cooking when planning the final result.
Step 6: Add Butter and Herbs
For extra flavor, place the steak on a plate and add a small piece of butter with a crushed garlic clove and a sprig of rosemary or thyme.
As the butter melts, spoon it over the steak.
This step is optional. A properly seasoned ribeye already has plenty of flavor from its beef, marbling, and browned crust.
Step 7: Rest the Steak
Transfer the steak to a warm plate or cutting board.
Let it rest for approximately 5–10 minutes, depending on its size and thickness.
Resting allows the temperature to equalize and makes the steak easier to slice without losing as much juice onto the cutting board.
Step 8: Slice and Serve
If serving the ribeye sliced, identify the direction of the muscle fibers and cut across them.
Slicing against the grain shortens the muscle fibers and makes each bite easier to chew.
Finish with a little flaky salt if desired, and serve with roasted potatoes, grilled vegetables, corn on the cob, or a crisp salad.
The Best Side Dishes for Ribeye Steak
Ribeye is rich and flavorful, so sides that provide freshness, acidity, or a contrasting texture work particularly well.
Garlic mashed potatoes: Creamy potatoes complement the steak’s savory flavor.
Grilled asparagus: A fresh vegetable side adds color without overwhelming the meat.
Roasted mushrooms: Their earthy flavor pairs naturally with beef.
Corn on the cob: Sweet corn offers a pleasant contrast to the savory steak.
Fresh garden salad: Crisp greens and a tangy vinaigrette help balance a rich meal.
Crispy roasted potatoes: Golden potatoes provide a satisfying texture alongside the steak’s browned crust.
Common Mistakes to Avoid When Grilling Ribeye
Cooking Straight From a Wet Surface
Moisture on the surface slows browning. Pat the steak dry before seasoning and grilling.
Using Excessively High Heat Throughout
High heat is excellent for searing, but it can burn the exterior before the center reaches the desired temperature. A two-zone grill gives you more control.
Guessing the Internal Temperature
Two steaks of the same thickness can cook differently because of their fat content, starting temperature, and grill conditions. Use a thermometer rather than relying entirely on cooking time.
Cutting the Steak Immediately
Cutting immediately after cooking allows more juice to escape onto the plate. Give the steak a few minutes to rest before serving.
Choosing Only by the Amount of White Fat
Marbling matters, but more visible fat does not automatically mean a better steak. Thickness, muscle structure, tenderness, aging, and personal preference also influence the final result.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is More Marbling Always Better?
Not necessarily. Marbling contributes flavor and richness, but the ideal amount depends on personal taste. Some people prefer heavily marbled ribeye, while others enjoy a leaner balance.
What Is the Ribeye Cap?
The ribeye cap, also called the spinalis dorsi, is the curved muscle that runs around the outside of the central ribeye eye. It is prized for its tenderness, rich flavor, and marbling.
Should I Buy Bone-In or Boneless Ribeye?
Both can be excellent. Boneless steaks are convenient and often easier to handle on the grill, while bone-in ribeye offers a traditional presentation. The bone does not automatically make the meat more flavorful or tender.
How Thick Should a Ribeye Be?
A steak approximately 1¼–1½ inches thick is a versatile choice for grilling. Thicker steaks provide more control over the balance between the crust and the center.
Can I Cook Ribeye in a Cast-Iron Skillet?
Absolutely. Preheat the skillet thoroughly, pat the steak dry, and sear it in a small amount of high-heat oil. Turn as needed, finish cooking to the appropriate internal temperature, and rest before slicing.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the perfect ribeye is about more than finding the steak with the most white streaks. Good marbling, even thickness, attractive muscle structure, and proper cooking all contribute to a delicious result.
Of the seven steaks in the picture, Number 3 would be my tentative choice based on its visible marbling and broad central muscle. But I would happily reconsider if another steak were thicker, had a better-developed ribeye cap, or offered a more appealing balance of meat and fat.
And that is part of the fun of choosing beef: every steak has its own character.
Now it’s your turn: Which number would you choose for the grill—1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, or 7? Would you pick the steak with the most marbling, the largest ribeye cap, or the most balanced shape?
See more on the next page
